Part 2 of the AI for ELA Teachers Series
If Brisk is where the feedback happens, NotebookLM is where everything starts to make sense.
This is the step where I stop feeling like I’m drowning in student writing and start seeing patterns: Who really understands CER? Which narrative skills are improving over time? Where do I need to reteach before the next big assignment?
In this post, I’m walking you through how I set up NotebookLM so it can:
- Read student writing with feedback included
- Learn my rubric
- Suggest holistic scores
- Store writing over time so I can track growth by genre
No tech jargon. No fancy prompts. Just clear steps you can follow.
What Is NotebookLM?
NotebookLM is a Google tool that lets you upload documents and then ask questions about them. Unlike other AI tools, it:
- Only uses the sources you upload
- Doesn’t search the open internet
- Doesn’t train on student work
- Keeps everything contained inside your notebook
For teachers, this makes it perfect for analyzing student writing safely.
How I Use NotebookLM in My Classroom
I create one notebook per genre for each class period:
- Narrative Writing
- Expository Writing
- Argument Writing
- CER / Constructed Responses
Over time, each notebook becomes a living archive of student writing, feedback, rubrics, and samples. That’s what allows NotebookLM to give meaningful insights later (which we’ll cover in Post 3).
Step 1: Create a New Notebook (One per Genre)
Open NotebookLM and click New Notebook.

Pro Tip:
Keep genres separate. This is what allows you to track genre-specific trends later instead of mixing everything together.
Step 2: Upload Your Sources (This Part Matters)
NotebookLM only knows what you teach it — so what you upload here is important.

Required Sources
- ✅ All student writing with Brisk feedback already on it
- ✅ The rubric used for scoring
Optional (but powerful)
- ⭐ Sample scored responses (high, middle, low)
- ⭐ Anchor papers
- ⭐ Model paragraphs
NotebookLM will process everything and list them as “sources.”
Step 3: Name it clearly
For example:
- Narrative Writing – 7th Grade
- CER Responses – Unit 2
- Argument Writing – 2025

Step 4: Ask for Suggested Holistic Scores
Once everything is uploaded, you’re ready to start asking questions.
This is the exact prompt I use (and recommend starting with):
“Using the uploaded rubric and feedback, suggest a holistic score for each student writing piece.”
NotebookLM will:
- Read the writing
- Reference the rubric
- Consider the feedback already given
- Suggest a score for each student
Important reminder
You are always the final decision-maker.
Think of this as a second set of eyes — not a replacement for your judgment.

Step 5: Spot Check for Accuracy
Before moving on:
- Open a few student pieces
- Compare NotebookLM’s suggested score with your instincts
- Adjust anything that feels off
Once you trust the results, you’re ready for the most powerful part of this workflow… data and trends.
That’s coming next.
Up Next: Turning Writing Into Actionable Data
In Post 3, I’ll show you how I use NotebookLM to:
- Generate spreadsheets automatically
- Summarize strengths and needs
- Identify class-wide trends
- Create small groups
- Generate mini-lesson ideas
- Prep reteaching before the next assignment
Download the Print-and-Go Quickstart Sheet

Download the 1-page Quickstart Sheet for Grades & Organize Feedback ⬇️

Leave a Reply